BarbeloPodcast Library
NewEconomicThinking
NewEconomicThinking·July 2, 2021

The Bonds of Inequality: How Municipal Debt and Racial Capitalism Shape American Cities

Watch on YouTube

Summary

The podcast features Dustin Jenkins, author of "The Bonds of Inequality," who discusses how municipal bond finance is not a neutral economic mechanism but a powerful generator of racial, spatial, and wealth inequality. Jenkins' interest in inequality began in childhood, observing the stark differences between income and wealth, and was sharpened by the 2008 financial crisis, highlighting how obscure institutions and individuals dramatically shape futures. His focus on municipal bonds solidified during the Detroit bankruptcy, where discussions of emergency managers and "taking a haircut" revealed deep questions of democracy, redistribution, and the racial politics of municipal debt in predominantly African American cities.

Jenkins argues that markets are political economic constructions, not benevolent, neutral forces. He illustrates this through the municipal bond market, where federal policies (like marginal tax rates making municipal bonds tax-exempt) and legislation (like the Glass-Steagall Act) profoundly shape who participates and benefits. He introduces the concept of "infrastructural investment in whiteness," where mid-20th century economic growth in cities like San Francisco was achieved by targeting consumption for middle-class white residents, employing segregated white labor for infrastructure, and redistributing wealth upwards to largely white, wealthy bondholders. This process actively reinscribed racial inequality through the allocation and distribution of funds.

A key distinction Jenkins makes is between "racial capitalism" and "racing capitalism." While both acknowledge race as fundamental to capitalism, racial capitalism often emphasizes its origin story and serves as a methodology to expose how finance, despite its technocratic language, is deeply intertwined with racialized bodies and outcomes. It challenges the notion that financial transactions are decoupled from racial inequality, revealing processes of exclusion and containment (e.g., plantation, ghetto, prison) and the selective allocation of rights. He cites James Baldwin's observation in the PBS documentary "Take This Hammer" about San Francisco's urban renewal ("negro removal") having "something to do with money," which Jenkins empirically links to real estate speculation and the role of major banks like Bank of America in financing both suburban growth and urban demolition.

Jenkins also reflects on the craft of scholarship, emphasizing the blend of art and science to make complex arguments digestible and impactful. He encourages young scholars to engage with the "dry stuff"—the mechanisms of domination—to identify pressure points for change, rather than solely focusing on resistance narratives. He highlights the historical example of CORE and NAACP's radical research agenda to disrupt Jim Crow finance by understanding the market for segregated municipal bonds. Jenkins expresses cautious optimism, noting that even within the bond buyer community, there's a growing recognition of the ethical and moral dimensions of financial transactions, often framed through ESG investing, suggesting a potential shift towards more conscious financial practices.

Key Quotes

"growth is not a neutral concept growth is a racialized concept"
"the individuals you've never heard of in the institutions about which you know little can dramatically shape your future"
"there was something that had something race had something to do with the politics of municipal debt"
"markets are political economic constructions"
"the business of debt proved to be a powerful generator of different and overlapping inequities"
"the infrastructural investment in whiteness targeting specific consent kenzian artifacts of consumption you might say to allow for middle class white folks to come in and consume downtown"
"racial capitalism as a methodology allows us to see that from the 20th century onwards which is my my kind of area of expertise lending buying selling was also always linked to race in some kind of way"
"all of this has something to do with money"
"how do you convey the terms of a story in ways that are digestible in ways that people have are able to grapple with and grasp"
"I encourage them to engage with the dry stuff the boring stuff the terms in other words against which people pushed"

Concepts

Themes

  • The racialized nature of economic systems and growth
  • The role of finance in perpetuating and exacerbating inequality
  • The political construction of markets
  • Historical roots of systemic racism in urban development and public finance
  • The interplay between state power, financial institutions, and social outcomes
  • The challenge of making complex academic work accessible and impactful
  • Activism and radical research as tools for social change
  • The ethics and morality of financial transactions

Related to:

Economics Insights

Market Implications

  • Perpetuation of racial and wealth inequality through municipal bond markets
  • Impact of emergency managers on local democracy and public services
  • Influence of federal tax policy on municipal bond attractiveness
  • Role of financial institutions in urban development and 'negro removal'

Key Concepts

  • Municipal bond finance
  • Racialized concept of growth
  • Infrastructural investment in whiteness
  • Racial capitalism
  • Austerity
  • Upward redistribution of wealth

Data Cited

  • Case studies of San Francisco and Detroit's municipal debt politics
  • Historical analysis of mid-20th century urban development funding

Practical Applications

  • Applying a 'radical research agenda' to uncover financial mechanisms of domination
  • Utilizing ESG frameworks to integrate ethics into financial transactions
  • Challenging the technocratic discourse of finance to reveal social impacts

Risks Mentioned

  • Erosion of local democracy through emergency management
  • Exacerbation of racial and spatial inequities via debt financing
  • Financial crises (e.g., 2008) highlighting systemic vulnerabilities

Similar Episodes