BarbeloPodcast Library
NewEconomicThinking
NewEconomicThinking·March 2, 2022

Regenerative Economics: A Paradigm Shift for a World in Crisis, Informed by Living Systems

Watch on YouTube

Summary

This podcast episode features John Fullerton, founder of the Capital Institute, discussing the urgent need for a paradigm shift from conventional neoclassical economics to a regenerative economic model. Fullerton, a former JP Morgan executive, recounts his journey from questioning the financial system after the Great Financial Crisis and 9/11 to exploring alternative frameworks rooted in living systems. He highlights the foundational flaws of neoclassical economics, which he argues is based on outdated Newtonian physics, assumes infinite growth on a finite planet, and fails to account for concepts like scale, interconnectedness, and planetary boundaries. The conversation emphasizes that the human economy, like all living systems, must operate within natural limits and follow principles of regeneration to be sustainable.

Fullerton introduces his eight principles of regenerative economics, drawing parallels between the self-sustaining processes observed in nature—from cellular regeneration in the human body to the evolution of the universe—and the necessary design principles for a healthy economy. He critiques the conventional economic focus on efficiency at the expense of resilience, advocating for a balance, often skewed towards resilience, as seen in healthy living systems. The discussion also touches on the importance of "empowered participation," where all parts of a system contribute to its health, moving beyond charity to systemic well-being, and the need to integrate holistic thinking, intuition, and balance (including masculine and feminine energies) into economic design.

The episode delves into the broader implications of this paradigm shift, noting its influence across various domains like healthcare (integrated medicine), education (transdisciplinary approaches), agriculture (regenerative agriculture), and architecture. Host Rob Johnson raises the psychological and political challenges of such a shift, acknowledging that fear often drives people back to familiar, albeit flawed, paradigms. Fullerton counters that the simplicity of the regenerative idea—that the human economy must behave like other living systems—is its strength, challenging anyone to argue that humanity is an exception to billions of years of evolutionary principles.

Ultimately, the conversation advocates for a fundamental re-evaluation of economic assumptions, moving away from reductionist logic towards a holistic understanding of our place within nature. It suggests that embracing indigenous wisdom and recognizing humanity as part of nature, not apart from it, is crucial for navigating global systemic crises like climate change and pandemics. The vision is not necessarily an end to human civilization but a potential "fall back to a lower level of complexity" if the necessary evolutionary corrections are not made, underscoring the urgency of adopting a regenerative approach for long-term societal and planetary health.

Key Quotes

"all parts of the system are empowered to participate in the health of the system"
"the health of humanity is harmed when the coal miners in west virginia are not empowered to participate in some new way in the economy we need"
"exponential growth on a finite planet can't continue forever"
"the neoclassical economic framework literally doesn't contemplate limits of the material expansion of the economy"
"our fundamental economics is built on a foundation that's designed for a different set of assumptions"
"what would an economic system design look like if it was designed around the patterns and principles of living systems?"
"the underlying assumptions was at the time of Adam Smith 1790s there was plenty of water and air relative to the size of the population and the use of resources but as that changed we're no longer in that place"
"regeneration is the actual process that living systems exhibit that enable them to be sustainable over the long period of time"
"we are a part of nature not apart from nature is the next big you know development in in in human civilization"
"healthy living systems exist in this sort of balance... between resiliency and efficiency"

Concepts

Themes

  • Critique of conventional economic paradigms
  • Interconnectedness of ecological, social, and economic systems
  • The necessity of a paradigm shift for sustainability
  • Lessons and principles derived from living systems
  • Planetary limits and the unsustainability of infinite growth
  • Holistic approaches to complex global challenges
  • The role of fear and political resistance in societal evolution
  • Re-evaluating fundamental assumptions about value and nature

Related to:

Economics Insights

Market Implications

  • Shift from optimizing efficiency to prioritizing resilience; re-evaluation of public goods and externalities; growth of impact investing; potential for lower levels of complexity and living standards if regenerative principles are ignored.

Key Concepts Critiqued

  • Neoclassical economics
  • Newtonian physics foundation of economics
  • Assumption of infinite growth
  • Lack of 'scale' in macroeconomics
  • Exchange value over use value
  • Efficiency optimization

Data Cited

  • MIT's 'Limits to Growth' (1973) model accuracy
  • Empirical studies by Bob Ulanowicz on resilience and efficiency in living systems

Practical Applications

  • Regenerative agriculture for sustainable food systems
  • Regenerative architecture for built environments
  • Integrated/integral medicine for holistic healthcare
  • Transdisciplinary education for comprehensive learning

Risks Mentioned

  • Breaching planetary boundaries (carbon cycle, water cycle)
  • Global systemic consequences (pandemics, climate change, biodiversity crisis)
  • Societal regression to lower levels of complexity
  • Political resistance to paradigm shifts ('merchants of doubt')
  • Stranded assets for those invested in old paradigms

Similar Episodes