BarbeloPodcast Library
DrTraceyMarks
DrTraceyMarks·September 12, 2018

The Genetics of Bipolar Disorder and Depression: Understanding Inherited Risk

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Dr. Tracey Marks, a psychiatrist, addresses the complex question of whether bipolar disorder and major depression are inherited, clarifying that their genetic transmission does not follow simple Mendelian genetics. Unlike single-gene disorders such as sickle-cell anemia, these mental health conditions are believed to arise from a combination of multiple genetic variations that collectively increase an individual's risk. The primary method for estimating this risk involves studying family histories and twin populations, which provide valuable insights into shared genetic predispositions.

A key distinction is made between first-degree relatives (parents, siblings, sharing 50% DNA) and second-degree relatives (grandparents, uncles, nieces/nephews, sharing 25% DNA), with the risk of developing a disorder being significantly higher for individuals with first-degree relatives affected. For bipolar disorder, the general population's lifetime risk is 0.5-1%, but this escalates to 15-30% if a first-degree relative is affected, and can reach up to 75% with two affected first-degree relatives. Major depression, while more prevalent in the general population (8-16%), is considered less strongly inherited than bipolar disorder, with a first-degree relative increasing the risk by two to four times, resulting in about a 15-16% chance. The episode also differentiates between unipolar (major) depression, characterized by depressive episodes only, and bipolar disorder, which includes both depressive and manic episodes.

Practically, Dr. Marks emphasizes that an increased genetic risk does not equate to an automatic diagnosis; it merely indicates a higher predisposition compared to the general population. Addressing a viewer's specific question about a grandchild's risk, she explains that while the risk is greater than for someone in the general population, it is less significant if the grandchild's parent (the viewer's daughter) is unaffected, as the grandchild is a second-degree relative to the viewer. A valuable clinical insight provided is that responses to psychiatric medications can also run in families, suggesting that if a close relative has found success with a particular medication, it could serve as a helpful starting point for treatment selection.

This discussion underscores the multifactorial nature of complex mental illnesses, highlighting the interplay between genetic predispositions and other factors (though environmental factors are not detailed in this segment). It stresses the importance of understanding family medical history for personalized risk assessment and guiding treatment strategies. The nuanced explanation of genetic inheritance for mental health conditions contrasts with simpler genetic models, emphasizing the ongoing challenges in precise prediction and the necessity for a comprehensive, individualized approach in clinical practice and patient education.

Key Quotes

for bipolar disorder there's a lifetime risk of a half to one percent for anyone whether you have a relative with her or not if you have a first degree relative with the disorder the risk goes up to 15 to 30 percent
the genetics with most illnesses do not follow men daily and genetics
bipolar disorder and depression can't be predicted like this we don't know exactly how the disorder comes about but it's thought to be a combination of several genetic variations that come together to increase the risk of developing the disorder
one of the ways we estimate risk is by studying families and twins
A first degree relative is someone who shares 50% of your DNA and this would be a parent or a sibling
if you have two first-degree relatives with it like your mother and your brother your risk increases up to 75% of developing it yourself
major depression or unipolar depression is thought not to be as inherited as bipolar disorder meaning it's not quite as passed down as strongly as bipolar disorder is
if you have a parent or sibling with either depression or bipolar disorder you are at greater risk of developing the disorder yourself but it doesn't automatically mean you will get it
just as these disorders can run in families responses to medications can also run in families

Concepts

Themes

  • Genetic predisposition vs. determinism
  • Complexity of mental illness inheritance
  • Family history in risk assessment
  • Nuance in genetic counseling
  • Personalized medicine (medication choice)
  • Mental health education
  • Risk stratification

Related to:

Health Insights

Clinical Recommendations

  • if you have depression and your sister has it and she's doing well on a certain medication there's a good chance that that drug could be a good choice for you

Mechanisms Explained

  • bipolar disorder and depression... thought to be a combination of several genetic variations that come together to increase the risk of developing the disorder

Risk Factors Discussed

  • first-degree relative with bipolar disorder
  • two first-degree relatives with bipolar disorder
  • first-degree relative with major depression

Genetic Principles Simplified

  • Mendelian genetics

Single Genetic Mutation Example

  • sickle-cell anemia

Multiple Genetic Variations Example

  • bipolar/depression

Similar Episodes